What do you think would finally be their, “Enough, we gotta say something!” situation?

Edit:
Put another way, what might serve as a cosmic icebreaker?

  • Excrubulent@slrpnk.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    16
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    This is one answer to the fermi paradox that makes no sense to me. If we did live in a dark forest universe where everyone was hiding from some oppressive existential threat, how would any of the civilisations learn about it?

    They would need to be in contact with one another to discover that other civilisations were being wiped out, but for that to happen, the wiping out civilisation would have to be able to find them as well. If they destroyed civ A, they’d definitely be able to find references to civ B in their ruins, somewhere. I see no mechanism by which a civilisation could observe this enemy in action without being detected.

    Unless someone has come up with an answer to this issue, in which case I’d like to see it.

    Also, if you can detect them, just telling them that you’ve detected them should change their strategy, because if a basic civilsation like ours can do it then they’re not actually that safe by hiding. The dark forest seems like a really fragile arrangement.

    • Timwi@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      15
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      11 months ago

      The oppressive existential threat you reference doesn’t need to exist for the universe to be a dark forest universe. It’s enough for every sufficiently advanced civilization to realize that such a threat could exist and remain quiet and hidden just in case.

      • Excrubulent@slrpnk.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        17
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        11 months ago

        Right but that’s fragile. All it takes is one group to break the ice and suddenly they’re all talking.

        Also, is the theory that we could live in a dark forest because every single species is insular enough to be afraid of such a threat? That means they all have to believe in the threat and yet also no species is aggressive enough to become the threat. But none of them thinks, “Wait, either we’re alone or everyone is hiding. If everyone is hiding, then the threat can’t exist, so we may as well say something.”

        Again, it’s fragile. I find it completely unconvincing.

        The Prime Directive concept is way more believable to me, as is the idea that life is just sparse.

        • GrabtharsHammer@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          6
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          11 months ago

          All it takes is one civilization to shoot off their mouth and get destroyed by a much more advanced neighbor, in some way that doesn’t look quite natural. That will tend to confirm the cosmic paranoia.

          • Excrubulent@slrpnk.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            6
            arrow-down
            2
            ·
            11 months ago

            As I said elsewhere: that’s no longer a dark forest. The moment one civilisation speaks up, they all know they’re not alone. Then they’re in a different universe, one where there’s no longer a paradox because they’ve found each other.

        • Timwi@kbin.social
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          11 months ago

          I do agree with your probability assessment; I too think that the Prime Directive is a more plausible answer to the Fermi paradox, as is “we’re just alone”.

          However, it is not necessarily the case that everyone suddenly gets talking as soon as one of them breaks radio silence. If everyone is silent because of a perceived possible threat, then it stands to reason they will continue to be silent even when they receive a message.

    • Deceptichum@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      11 months ago

      Well if you’re an advanced alien race, imagine hearing this on your airwaves

      “What a joyous day, our messages have been received we’ve made first contact with an unidentified vessel in our solar system “

      A few days later

      “oh god why? They’re killing everyone it’s a slaughter out there”

      And radio silence.

      And imagine every time you hear something it ends the same way.

      • Excrubulent@slrpnk.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        14
        ·
        11 months ago

        Right but then that relies on not existing in a dark forest. That is, you can detect signs of alien life, but then those signs tell you horrible things.

        The situation we have is that we see nothing.

        I guess the answer is that some civilisations reach a point where they broadcast themselves and get destroyed, whilst other civilisations reach a point where they receive those broadcasts and don’t reply before hearing the other civilisation get destroyed. So somehow they were listening at the exact right moment to discover that others are getting killed without responding, and that happened enough times that there is a whole universe full of quiet civilisations.

        I still don’t see the A to B. I cannot imagine any species curious enough to detect alien life and insular enough to not respond. If we got those signs we would reply immediately, almost definitely.