Believe it or not there was once a lot of good will towards Reddit.

So I can still see beehaw communities here and comment on them but if I do they won’t show up to beehaw users?

If that’s the case then we really need some indication/warning sign that the instance is defederated, or else people will be talking into the void if they don’t keep close track of which instances are/aren’t defederated.

I hate to say this because it may be elitist, but it’s been on my mind since joining yesterday: the fact that Lemmy is relatively unknown and relatively difficult to sign up to acts as a good filter at the moment. It’s like the early days of the internet where you had to be a certain kind of nerd to have a computer and a modem. It’s been great, like the old days.

I know the lemmygrad.ml instance claims to be Marxist but I don’t think they’re generally taken that seriously (and not to be confused with lemmy.ml) - is that what you’re confusing? Apart from that, the federal nature of Lemmy means it doesn’t really matter what the creator’s political beliefs are.

A relatively small thing: the 500-comment viewing limit for normal accounts. So many times on Reddit I’ve been put off engaging with posts with 500+ comments knowing that nobody would see it. It’s stupid because comments are just text and unless the software design is absolutely terrible then simple text comments shouldn’t take up bandwidth at all.

In my mind, it only needs to be a fraction of the size of Reddit to be potentially successful. I’ve been using online forums since the 90s, back in the day there were some forums with great long-lasting communities that had only a couple of dozen regular members. Sometimes a smaller forum is better than a larger one. Granted it’s different since forums generally specialised in one topic, but don’t forget the days where you didn’t need to be a huge all-encompassing platform to be successful, especially when you’re not trying to make money from it.

Interface is better than “new” Reddit, not as good as old Reddit + RES.

Also: if I click on a link on another instance (for example https://lemmy.ml/c/asklemmy when I’m signed in on lemmy.world), I’m not signed in to lemmy.ml so I have to manually search for it in lemmy.world to post there - is there a common solution to that?